Dear all, I would like to receive your best advice, about a difficult situation I am having against an auction house in Germany, because of a phone bidding. The auction house deals with stamps and coins. I would like to say that I have purchased many coins in Germany, without any problem.
Unfortunately I only speak English, but I would appreciate your support, even in German (who can I call? What should I do?).
INTRODUCTION: before the auction, I mailed the auction house (in English), asking if it would have been possible to take part to their coin auction via phone, so that I could have bid for some lots in real time, while they were taking the auction in their premises.
After the positive response from the auction house, I sent a first offer about 3 lots I am interested about (they requested to do like that) and I kindly ask them to be contacted the day of the auction, in order to make a new bid if necessary.
I was interested at:
Lot 7633, my starting offer was 150 Euro
Lot 7635, my starting offer was 80 Euro
Lot 7756, my starting offer was 140 Euro
On May, 24th, before the official start of the auction, I go and see their website, in order to be prepared about the order of the lots and to be ready to offer when receiving the phone call.
All my 3 lots are regularly in the website, with no additional relevant information. According to the website, I should have received the call in the late morning.
Finally I got a first phone call in the afternoon, but I immediately realized that the English level of my contact person from the auction house was really poor. Since I have lived for 5 years abroad, I have a good level of English .
I am able to understand that he is going to tell me the highest bid, informing that I should have told him “OK” every time that I wanted to do a new bid. Considering his poor level of English, I invite him to spell every single number, in order not to have any misunderstanding.
In this moment the auction make a mistake: The contact person refers that the prize for the lot is arrived now at the amount of 150 Euros, but they do not say that that prize refers to lot 7635 and not to lot 7633(which I would have been keen to buy at that prize). This happens because lots 7633 and lot 7634 have been taken out from the auction, maybe they were not authentic (?), but in no circumstance the auction house has informed me that this has happened. So when I offered for 150, in the reality they took the offer for lot 7635, amount that I was not meant to offer for that lot.
The contact person at the beginning does not realize this either, only at the end of the phone call (when he had already made the wrong offer), understanding that something went wrong, he tells me that the lot I was interested was not authentic and for this reason taken out.
INVOICE: On June 1st, after receiving an invoice with a wrong assignment of the lot, immediately I send a polite email to the auction house, informing about their mistake.
But the answer of auction house on june 2nd is negative, they deny any mistake and ask me to pay the invoice,
Of course I deny that I am willing to pay for something it is not mistake and they arrived to threaten me, threatening to put me on the list of fraudulent buyers, so no German auction house will take bids from me.
I asked if they were recording the conversation, but they did not.
On june 6th, after a phone conversation trying to find a solution, I mail the auction house that I will proceed in paying the lot I have really won, but not the other one (which was wrongly assigned).On june 8th, having not received any feedback I proceeded to the payment.
So, they have my money for the coin I have really won, but they do not send the coin (they want all the invoice paid). I have involved the European Consumer Association, but they do not look really expert in the topic, so what should I do?
Thank you,
F.f.
Unfortunately I only speak English, but I would appreciate your support, even in German (who can I call? What should I do?).
INTRODUCTION: before the auction, I mailed the auction house (in English), asking if it would have been possible to take part to their coin auction via phone, so that I could have bid for some lots in real time, while they were taking the auction in their premises.
After the positive response from the auction house, I sent a first offer about 3 lots I am interested about (they requested to do like that) and I kindly ask them to be contacted the day of the auction, in order to make a new bid if necessary.
I was interested at:
Lot 7633, my starting offer was 150 Euro
Lot 7635, my starting offer was 80 Euro
Lot 7756, my starting offer was 140 Euro
On May, 24th, before the official start of the auction, I go and see their website, in order to be prepared about the order of the lots and to be ready to offer when receiving the phone call.
All my 3 lots are regularly in the website, with no additional relevant information. According to the website, I should have received the call in the late morning.
Finally I got a first phone call in the afternoon, but I immediately realized that the English level of my contact person from the auction house was really poor. Since I have lived for 5 years abroad, I have a good level of English .
I am able to understand that he is going to tell me the highest bid, informing that I should have told him “OK” every time that I wanted to do a new bid. Considering his poor level of English, I invite him to spell every single number, in order not to have any misunderstanding.
In this moment the auction make a mistake: The contact person refers that the prize for the lot is arrived now at the amount of 150 Euros, but they do not say that that prize refers to lot 7635 and not to lot 7633(which I would have been keen to buy at that prize). This happens because lots 7633 and lot 7634 have been taken out from the auction, maybe they were not authentic (?), but in no circumstance the auction house has informed me that this has happened. So when I offered for 150, in the reality they took the offer for lot 7635, amount that I was not meant to offer for that lot.
The contact person at the beginning does not realize this either, only at the end of the phone call (when he had already made the wrong offer), understanding that something went wrong, he tells me that the lot I was interested was not authentic and for this reason taken out.
INVOICE: On June 1st, after receiving an invoice with a wrong assignment of the lot, immediately I send a polite email to the auction house, informing about their mistake.
But the answer of auction house on june 2nd is negative, they deny any mistake and ask me to pay the invoice,
Of course I deny that I am willing to pay for something it is not mistake and they arrived to threaten me, threatening to put me on the list of fraudulent buyers, so no German auction house will take bids from me.
I asked if they were recording the conversation, but they did not.
On june 6th, after a phone conversation trying to find a solution, I mail the auction house that I will proceed in paying the lot I have really won, but not the other one (which was wrongly assigned).On june 8th, having not received any feedback I proceeded to the payment.
So, they have my money for the coin I have really won, but they do not send the coin (they want all the invoice paid). I have involved the European Consumer Association, but they do not look really expert in the topic, so what should I do?
Thank you,
F.f.
Honscha.Muenzen